Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) Chair Michael Selig says state prosecutions could put prediction market founders in jail.
He argues that federal derivatives law protects the contracts at issue. State officials say sports event contracts fall under their gambling laws. The dispute now tests both the scope of federal oversight and the limits of state enforcement.
Utah felony charges bring jail risk into focus
In a November 13 CNBC interview at Cantor Convergence, Selig called the states’ use of criminal charges “really egregious.” He said the companies offer lawful products under federal rules and urged the Supreme Court to resolve the dispute. “That’s not something that should be at the risk of going to jail,” he said.
Utah filed felony charges against Kalshi and cofounders Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara in October. Utah alleges the company promoted illegal online gambling by letting users in the state wager on sports. The charges carry possible jail time. The case has produced no convictions. Prosecutors have yet to specify what penalties they would seek.
On November 13, the CFTC sued Louisiana after a state judge ordered more than 30 companies to halt operations there. The agency said those companies had ties to federally regulated derivatives and received neither notice nor a hearing. Louisiana became the 12th state the CFTC sued over its jurisdiction. The agency has also filed briefs in four federal appeals courts and one state supreme court.
Separately, the Justice Department and CFTC challenged Arkansas Attorney General Tim Griffin’s enforcement action against Kalshi.
New Jersey asks Supreme Court to settle split
New Jersey officials petitioned the Supreme Court after the Third Circuit sided with Kalshi. The petition asks whether the Dodd-Frank Act bars states from applying gambling laws to sports contracts on CFTC-registered exchanges. The Ninth Circuit reached the opposite conclusion. The Sixth Circuit denied interim relief and left the underlying question open.
Stanford law professor Joe Grundfest expects the justices to take up the dispute. The court has yet to agree to hear New Jersey’s case. Kalshi’s response is due December 7.
In July, 44 state attorneys general argued that Congress gave the CFTC no authority to regulate sports wagers as derivatives. They said those wagers serve neither a hedging nor a price discovery function. The National Conference of State Legislatures cited an American Gaming Association estimate of lost tax revenue. The group estimated prediction markets displaced more than $1 billion in state sports-betting taxes.
State rules could split prediction market liquidity
DefiLlama tracked about $6.25 billion in seven-day trading volume across 138 prediction market protocols as of November 14. Kalshi accounted for $4.54 billion and Polymarket $1.34 billion. The figures cover only platforms DefiLlama monitors.
Conflicting state rules could increase compliance costs, limit trader access and fragment liquidity. In Britain, prediction markets generally require betting intermediary licences, depending on their structure, according to Norton Rose Fulbright. Financial instruments fall under separate oversight.
A Senate Banking Committee aide told Reuters that Senator Elizabeth Warren plans closer oversight of prediction markets. Those plans hinge on her taking the committee chair in January. Selig maintains that the CFTC has exclusive jurisdiction over the markets.

